D&D got a way with a lot of bad habits, because it was the only game in town. People are expected to read the core rules, then the Dungeon Master's Guide, then an adventure. I've copied their style, and only now realized the error of front-loading MAXIMUM RULES. The order of books in this case is: Core Rules …

Read More

Software engineers regularly jump into others' open source, and help out, but the RPG community do not do the same, because they do not have the right tools. Look throughout the history of any number of software projects and you'll find a slew of apparently random people, unknown to the software's creator, jumping in …

Read More

RPGs where nobody dies really irk me, because they have rules for dying. If you want an RPG where nobody ever dies (or runs out of food, or whatever), then I won't complain...until the rulebook states 'these are the conditions for death'. We have two problems. Problem 1: Fudging GMs Everyone writes up some dramatic …

Read More

Dice can give unexpected results when groups of people roll. When a group of 5 players need to roll to sneak past a guard, you already know someone will fail, because they have 5 chances to fail. If everyone rolls for Alertness, they will succeed every time, because they have five chances to succeed. The Alertness roll …

Read More

Ideas on Campaigns with Real-time synchronization seemed interesting, but I'm unsure how they will interact with my Story Weaving methods of constructing adventures. Presumably, if nobody who started part 1 of a thread is present, then part 2 will simply not appear. But what if 1 party member who saw part 1 is present? …

Read More

Whenever I'm unsure about a rule, I pull out a basic spreadsheet, and start populating numbers. The image I had for the ghoul spell began with a mage who could raise small things from the dead, like a cat, or dog. Slowly, the dark sorcerer would learn to raise gnomes, then humans, and finally raise undead ogres or …

Read More

I've found myself aghast at the multiple (not loads, but still) conversations I've had online where I've proposed an open-source RPG, and I'm told that this really isn't adding much, because people can already copy systems. I have personally copied a system. I have rewritten White Wolf's rules so that I could modify …

Read More

A lot of people are their own worst critic. In my case this is trivial, because I'm my only critic - very few people have seen BIND yet. Anyway - here are the problems I want to address in the form of a shitty review. BIND jumps from body-horror with the nura, and griffins eating babies, to semi-comedic nonsense like …

Read More

The previous post went over changing BIND's Combat system significantly, but I've not been able to resolve the problems. Every change I make demands other fixes. Everything I fix breaks something else. Once combat's simplified, the shield's don't work. Or they work with swords, but don't provide any use when holding a …

Read More

I warned ye! but did you listen to me? Oh no you knew didn't ye? It's just a harmless little licence, isn't it? ...sorry, just had to get that off my chest.

Read More